Amazon.com Review
It’s rare for a book’s title to say so clearly what the book is about. In the case of Rupert Sheldrake’s latest work, the controversial content is right on the front cover. Pet owners will see it and smile in recognition; skeptical scientists will shake their heads and mutter about “maverick scholars.” We all know of cases of dogs (and cats) who know when their owners are coming home, who go to wait at the door or window 10 minutes or more before their human arrives. Conditioned by the tight rigor of contemporary scientific thinking, we either look for rational explanations or we file the phenomenon away in our minds as “unexplained” and are careful not to talk about it with our scientist friends.
Sheldrake has shown in the past that he is not afraid to be labeled a rebel, thanks to his theory of morphic resonance, which suggests the following:
Natural systems, or morphic units, at all levels of complexity are animated, organized, and coordinated by morphic fields, which contain an inherent memory. Natural systems inherit this collective memory from all previous things of their kind by a process called morphic resonance, with the result that patterns of development and behavior become increasingly habitual through repetition.
Sheldrake believes that the “telepathy” between pets and humans, or between flocks of birds or schools of fish that move as a single organism, can be explained this theory. Sheldrake is less persuaded by anecdotes that suggest animal clairvoyance—warning of something in the near future—but refuses to disallow the possibility.
He accepts that the case histories he details so thoroughly in this book are anecdotal, but that makes them no less real; and as a scientist himself he sets up experimental conditions for studying this previously ignored phenomenon that show beyond any doubt that the phenomenon exists. He castigates traditional scientists for their refusal to countenance anything that doesn’t fit in with their existing paradigms (or prejudices) and challenges them to come up with some more “acceptable” explanation—but none is forthcoming.
This fascinating book is a first attempt at a scientific investigation into a puzzling but quite common occurrence. One hopes that other scientists will follow Sheldrake’s brave lead.—David V. Barrett http://www.amazon.com/Dogs-That-Their-Owners-Coming/dp/0609600923
He accepts that the case histories he details so thoroughly in this book are anecdotal, but that makes them no less real; and as a scientist himself he sets up experimental conditions for studying this previously ignored phenomenon that show beyond any doubt that the phenomenon exists.
This sounds like the same sort of “science” that the Creationists use.
Also, my dog hates it when I put cottage cheese on my unmentionable parts. I mean, he loves cheese, but he hates when I put it “there”.
You need to snap out of this compulsion…..do you want that dog to grow up to be a serial killer, or druggie? Shame on you. Cottage cheese should not be messed with.
When i was younger, my dog always knew when my mom was coming home from work.
I always figured it was because he had good ears, like most dogs. And she was driving a truck on a long, gravel road.
Come to find out he was telepathic!
When I was in high school, my mom said that she would know when I’d be home in ten minutes because my cat would leave her usual begging spot in the kitchen to wait at the front door.
I do understand that a cat is not a dog, but I found this to be an interesting older thread to bump.
When i was younger, my dog always knew when my mom was coming home from work.
I always figured it was because he had good ears, like most dogs. And she was driving a truck on a long, gravel road.
Come to find out he was telepathic!
When I was in high school, my mom said that she would know when I’d be home in ten minutes because my cat would leave her usual begging spot in the kitchen to wait at the front door.
I do understand that a cat is not a dog, but I found this to be an interesting older thread to bump.
I don’t think olfactory responses are extrasensory.
