bobaloo - 29 April 2009 11:36 AM
Thomas38 - 28 April 2009 07:18 AM
Jones was a sick Christian cult leader, not a religious man at all, more a mentally ill demagogue obsessed with power, power he could only manage to exercise over the downtrodden and ignorant people he preyed upon.
The fact that you identify him as a Christian then say he wasn’t a religious man at all, which I agree with, is ridiculous. Why link him to Christianity in any way?
Being a Christian or a Muslim or any other faith doesn’t make a person religious, just a member of a religion. That being said I misspoke. He was a student pastor of a Methodist Church at one time but left the church because of a policy against black people becoming members.
The question here is whether or not being a disciple of Osho makes one a cult member. I say not as the definition of cult is fairly clear. Osho did not found a religion, was not the object of worship, taught no creed, demanded no fealty and was not teaching any religious tradition. He was born into a Jain family but did not follow the religion of his parents. They, in fact, became his disciples.
As for knowing about Osho in terms of opining, I submit that looking from the outside is far different than looking from the inside. It’s, if you will, a case of unless you’ve walked a mile in the other guys shoes you can’t know his experience.
In a sense, the difficulty with this whole sub-forum is simply the fact that unless you are involved in whatever religious pursuits you are speaking about you cannot, in fact, know any more than second hand what it’s about. This makes it a very difficult topic to join in debate about unless all are looking from the same perspective more or less.
Now you might say then “Tom, you have no business commenting on Christianity, you’re not a Christian”, to which I must answer, I was raised a Christian, baptized a Methodist, was involved in various church activities until approximately 1967 and left the church purely because it was not meeting my needs. By the way, though I reject totally all organized religions fro some very credible reasons, I do not label myself an atheist. In my milieu no labels are applied. We are all individuals who, more or less, take a wait and see stance. Osho has stated “There is no god, only godliness”. That being said, Osho is a tremendously contradictory man thus one cannot rightly conclude anything about god from what he has said.